Delco Tries Public Ownership After Private Equity Raided Its Hospital Network

Nether Providence, Rose Valley, Rutledge, Swarthmore and Upper Providence approved it Wednesday. Media pulled out. And the fee model means tax-exempt institutions pay their share for the ambulance.

Share
Delco Tries Public Ownership After Private Equity Raided Its Hospital Network

(5) Delco municipalities voted Wednesday night to build a public authority that owns and runs an essential service.

Nether Providence, Rose Valley, Rutledge, Swarthmore and Upper Providence approved ordinances creating the Municipal Emergency Medical Services Authority of Delaware County. Providing advanced life support, while being governed by a board those towns appoint.

Media was in the group but pulled themselves out last week.

What happened

All (5) held their own special meetings the same night at Strath Haven Middle School and each named a board representative.

Nether Providence, Rose Valley, Rutledge and Swarthmore were unanimous, while Upper Providence voted 3-1.

Maureen Scheuerman was the lone elected official to vote against the creation of a new EMS authority. This is completely irresponsible.

The board has Nether Providence commissioner Max Cooper, former Rose Valley councilmember David Firn, Rutledge fire marshal Thomas Moleski, former Swarthmore councilmember Kristen Seymore, and former Upper Providence council member Christen Rexing.

The recommended resident fee is $95 a year, which Cooper said is a starting point and can be modified at future public hearings. Businesses, nonprofits and the municipalities themselves pay too.

It doesn’t go into service immediately. The new board will be deciding staffing and more, & a partnership with Main Line Health is being discussed. Swarthmore Mayor Booth laid out the options…contract just the staff, own the ambulances and equipment, or contract the whole service and manage it.

Max Cooper made the point that the fee model means nonprofits contribute. While under a tax based model they wouldn’t pay a dime.

So Swarthmore College, churches, hospitals. Every tax exempt property in those five towns that calls 911 like everybody else and currently pays nothing toward the ambulance. The fee structure is how you make institutions pay for a service they use…especially if the state isn’t doing us any favors in terms of avenues to raise revenue.

Media left

Media was in the group from the beginning. Borough Manager Brittany Forman said council directed her to compare projected 2027 costs under their existing Main Line Health contract against what the authority’s fees would cost taxpayers/businesses. And staying with Main Line Health came out cheaper.

The whole argument for the authority is that pooling risk across more people makes the service stable and the cost per household lower. Media leaving makes it more expensive for the five towns that stayed. And Media had the option to leave because it already had an existing private contract.

A municipality with a cheaper private alternative opts out because they didn’t want the optics of a tax increase…and instead wanted the political win of “we don’t have to raise taxes or fees given our good situation” … at the same time the public system gets a little weaker.

Being left out

Building this took about (18) months of unpaid labor. One of the organizers is a township commissioner and a former Crozer emergency physician, so an enormous amount of professional capacity, donated.

Chester is bankrupt and signed a contract, because they have no capacity to build any sort of alternative.

So the towns with capacity get a public utility they govern, but the towns without it get a vendor. And a vendor can raise its price, cut staffing, or even just walk out of the contract all together, which is exactly the type of situation that created this crisis..

Whats next?

The authority has room for additional members. The barrier for Chester or Darby or Collingdale could be the $$ and the eighteen months. But the county could legally pay the costs for any municipality that wants in and can’t afford to build one.

The board sets the actual fee, and the $95 number isnt final.

Know someone in Delco who should see this?

Read more