"These Are All Marple Newtown Tigers": Support Program Study Proposal Triggers Anxiety and Explanations

Residents came prepared to fight an emotional support program move, but district officials laid out a gradual approach, and explained why they thought everyone would benefit from the changes. 

Share
"These Are All Marple Newtown Tigers": Support Program Study Proposal Triggers Anxiety and Explanations
The front of W.F. Loomis Elementary School | Photo by Nick Giannini

Residents came prepared to fight an emotional support program move, but district officials laid out a gradual approach, and explained why they thought everyone would benefit from the changes. 

The Marple Newtown school board voted Tuesday night to let the administration study the feasibility of opening an intensive emotional support program at Loomis Elementary, over objections from residents who arrived with prepared statements and a list of questions.

The Study’s Focus

At the board's Oct. 13 committee meeting, Assistant Superintendent Dr. Kevin Fagan asked for permission to spend the winter studying whether to open an intensive emotional support program at Loomis, with the intention of shifting the program out of Russell Elementary, it’s current home over the next two or more years. 

Marple Newtown runs intensive special education in three areas — autistic support, emotional support and life skills — and currently does it at two of its four elementary schools. Culbertson hosts the intensive autism program. Russell hosts the other two. Loomis hosts none.

The emotional support program at Russell serves about 12 students across kindergarten through fifth grade. Rather than a separate classroom, students go to classes, specials and lunch like everyone else, with staff trained to respond to behavioral triggers in the moment. 

It is staffed by one full-time teacher and one registered behavioral technician, and that technician is split between the emotional support and life skills programs.

The reason the district is looking at Loomis has less to do with Loomis than with Russell. Running two intensive programs in one building is "proving to be a lot for that staff and for that building." 

No Moves For Existing Students

There was vehement opposition, but much of it seemed based on a misunderstanding. Several parents that spoke were under the impression that any change would mean moving existing students in the program from their current school to Loomis. 

One resident, who read a prepared statement brought up that children in intensive emotional support "may depend heavily on predictable routines, familiar surroundings, established relationships," and a relocation "could set this program back years and undo any progress."

Officials was quick to respond with both empathy and clarity.  While they understood the concerns, they promised "We're not doing anything without a lot of care,” and said that moving existing students was never on the table. If the program moved, existing students would matriculate up at Russell, as new students were added at Loomis. Effectively there would be a gradual draw down at the old location, and a corresponding intake at the other. 

They emphasized that their first and foremost concern was for the student experience:  "These are all Marple Newtown Tigers. They're all of our students,” Fagan told attendees. 

Other Concerns

Though the issue of existing students seemed to be the biggest concern, public comment brought up other concerns, including more transparency about why the current location is inadequate, a better understanding around facility or staffing shortage and the expense of the move. 

One resident argued that there was alright a staffing shortage at Russell, and wondered if the gradual transfer would stretch resources even further, lowering care at both locations. 

This was the very reason a feasibility study needs to be conducted, Fagan and Kane explained. They admitted that the existing program needed additional staffing and support. Part of what the study will look at is how an additional staff can be paid for, both in the short and long term. 

They were also clear that the study was in no way a formality. It may reveal that a move would be untenable for financial or logistical reasons. But everyone agreed on the need for additional resources. 

As Fagan put it: "Currently we have two specialized programs at Russell and they are relatively intense — maybe not in terms of numbers, but in terms of need," Fagan said. "Over the last several years we have seen the level of need increase. And what we are witnessing right now at Russell is that we are over-taxing that staff, and we have to create some relief."

Culbertson's autism program has grown too, he said, and does well. "The difference is because we house two programs there, our staff is being stretched very thin." Loomis, by contrast, has no intensive program and has space.

He also argued that the  a school gains something by hosting one of these programs.

"These are our kids and they have needs that we are required to meet as a public school system, and they're members of our community — and the school itself benefits from programs like that," he said. "I know that sounds counterintuitive, but it does. This is a learning and growing opportunity for the staff. It's a learning and growing opportunity for the other students."

Then he offered himself as evidence. "My own children attended the school where I was principal. My own children were around that program, and I can tell you from firsthand experience that they learned from those kids. They did. They benefited from them."

Officials have already met with both principals, with key staff at both schools, and had gone to Loomis in person the previous week to talk it through with the staff face to face. 

A Commitment to Transparency

Bilker made a commitment on the record.

"At the time that this study is finished — whenever that may be — we communicate with the district, with Russell, with Loomis, with whoever wants to be here, and we'll do this breakdown at a committee meeting," he said. 

Committee meetings run two weeks before each regular meeting. "It's an informative discussion where you can listen, you'll have the ability to comment after that is done, and then the board has a couple of weeks to consider where they're at — if they want to move forward, if we don't want to move forward."

He added:  "It should not be hastily done. It should not be something that's just 'ah, we're going to pick this up and move it over here.' And I don't think our team is treating it that way."

The board then approved the study on a voice vote, with no audible opposition. No completion date was given.

Also at the meeting

A new principal at Loomis. Jaime Smyth is retiring after eight years leading the school — and going back to the classroom to teach fifth grade. "Jamie and I started together," Kane said. "She was a new principal at Loomis and I was a new superintendent here." The board was full of praise, jokingly threatening to vote no on the motion out of a desire for her to stay. 

The board appointed Rick Martin to succeed her. Kane said he comes with elementary and middle school teaching experience and has been an assistant principal at both levels.

Joe Sheehan is retiring as supervisor of transportation. "He's an unsung hero," Kane said. "Joe's here super duper early. Joe and I manage snow calls together."

Eight National Merit commended students were honored at the high school — the most in Principal John Beltrante's nine years there, up from six last year. Commended students place among the roughly 50,000 highest scorers on the PSAT/NMSQT nationally.

MN Drama invited the board to A Christmas Carol on Nov. 19, 20 and 21 at 7 p.m., brought candles, and asked permission to put lawn signs outside the elementary and middle schools. Bilker said yes — "since it's a Marple Newtown event, you are permitted to advertise on all of our school grounds" — and added that he had already bought tickets for opening night.

The student representative reported a dense October: the 56th Bandarama, the fall LINK retreat, the 31st Junior Initiative speakers conference, homecoming week and dance, Red Ribbon Week, trunk-or-treats at Russell and Culbertson, and a bocce team gearing up for the Polar Plunge to benefit Special Olympics.

Kane reported that every PTO has a fall fundraiser running, and that a new panel covering the last decade has been hung on the high school's historic timeline, sponsored by the Becker family.

Know someone in Delco who should see this?

Read more