Trainer Council Confirms Closed-Door Data Center Meetings, Including One on a Community Benefits Package

The council president says he is not at liberty to discuss what was offered, and that the borough’s only information on the Ridge Road proposal comes from the developer’s own website.

Share
Trainer Council Confirms Closed-Door Data Center Meetings, Including One on a Community Benefits Package
Preliminary test fit provided by Link Logistics in its request for a zoning determination.

Background: The fight over a possible data center at the former Congoleum site in Trainer goes before the borough's zoning hearing board Nov. 17.

The roughly 24-acre property at 4001 Ridge Road straddles the town line, with about 90% in Trainer and 10% in Lower Chichester. Industrial real estate company Link Logistics bought it in 2022.

In July, Lower Chichester's zoning officer found that a data center isn't permitted on the township's portion. In August, a lawyer for Link Logistics asked Trainer's zoning officer the same question. The borough issued a preliminary opinion that a data center is allowed by right, though other approvals would still be needed.

That opinion is now under appeal.


Closed-door meetings

Council president John Gaspero made a statement about the current questions and accusations regarding a proposed data center. He stated that there have been several meetings to discuss the data center, a fact which had been previously denied by the council, and that the meetings were executive sessions or presentation meetings, which do not need to be made public because they did not include votes or decision-making. He stated that one meeting discussed a community benefits package, but they are not liberty to discuss it now. He said everything council knows about the project is on a website. A resident called out that the site was Link’s own, and Gaspero confirmed it was.

That site, 4001ridgeroad.com, identifies Link as its sponsor. It says the facility would use closed-loop cooling, that Link would fund all of the electrical grid upgrades needed to serve it, and that job, tax revenue and noise figures will be shared once a design is under review. On community benefits it says only that Link will share planned philanthropic investment and that workforce development is a priority.

Council separately authorized solicitor Chris Boggs to attend the Nov. 17 zoning hearing board appeal. A speaker said that hearing has been moved to the IBEW Local 654 hall in Upper Chichester to accommodate a larger crowd. If Link holds a public presentation, Gaspero said, the company decides where, though council would push for a bigger room.

Residents press council

During the time for public comment, a Trainer resident asked each of the councilmembers how they would personally feel about a data center being built in the neighborhood. Councilmembers did not respond. The Mayor answered that she currently has no opinion about a data center, and wants to hear both sides of the situation before forming an opinion. Residents noted that council has already held a private informational session with Link Logistics, so they should be aware of the benefits of a data center.

One resident agreed with the mayor, stating that he wants to let Link Logistics argue their side before siding against the data center. Other residents requested that the council research the issues associated with data centers so that they are able to protect residents and keep the local children healthy.

Threats condemned

Resident Rafael Hernandez, who said he has been helping organize neighbors against the project, read a prepared statement saying he had heard that some council members and some data center supporters may have been threatened, and that he condemns threats and intimidation of any kind, whoever is responsible. He urged anyone who has been threatened to call police.

One council member stated that some children wouldn't come to her house on Halloween because their parents were associated with Hernandez's organization. Other council members responded by claiming that Hernandez himself had made a threatening post towards the council on Facebook. Hernandez denied the accusation and asked to see the posts. He was told it was no longer online and that someone was working to recover it. Delco Rising has not seen the post.

Transparency concerns

Residents raised concerns that the council was not operating transparently, especially in regards to the appointments to the planning commission. A resident said she applied on Oct. 13 and was told about three hours later that the positions were filled, and that a post saying the same went up that afternoon. She said no selection or deliberation had taken place at any public meeting, and cited the Sunshine Act, which allow council to discuss appointments in executive session but require the official action to be taken in open meeting. She also cited Section 203 of the Municipalities Planning Code, which governs how planning commission members are appointed. She said she has filed a Right-to-Know request for records of the process.

Rafael Hernandez also spoke about the planning commission. He expressed that there are people who have been interested in joining the commission for years, including people who regularly attend the council meetings and are active in the community. The council filled all five of those positions at once. Hernandez asked if the appointments were made so that the commission would vote in favor of the data center.

He also noted that the council's decision to disband the property maintenance committee was said to be due to low participation and inactivity. Hernandez is on the committee and says that it is active. He asked for explanations regarding the planning commission and property maintenance committee. Gaspero cut him off at the two-minute limit, and council did not answer his questions.

Later in the meeting council voted to appoint five members to the commission: Mike Petrillo, Greg Miley, Rhonda Matthews, Fatima De La Cruz and Bill Walsh. It also voted to disband the property maintenance committee, which Gaspero said is not required and had one member left, with code enforcement already covering the work.

Right-to-know handover

Council voted to accept the resignation of Victoria Orlando as the borough’s Right-to-Know officer and to appoint borough manager Mark Possenti in her place. Possenti said Orlando resigned at the end of October and that he had been handling requests in the interim because the law requires the borough to have someone in the role. A resident who had filed a request challenged whether he had authority to answer it and whether his response was late. Possenti said the five-business-day clock started when the office reopened and that he met it. The resident has appealed, which Possenti said puts the request on hold.

CDBG suggestions

Borough Engineer Eileen Mulvena led a discussion on the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG). At this time of the year, local municipalities can apply for federal funding to improve communities. She asked residents at the meeting to suggest projects that could be included in the grant application.

Mulvena also told residents that only part of the borough is eligible — the area from Township Line Road to Post Road — because the eligibility map is set by 2016–2020 census data identifying low-to-moderate income areas. Several residents objected that this excludes 2nd Street, 3rd Street and the blocks toward Route 291, where the census recorded no population. Officials said the boundary is not the borough’s to set and that an area can become eligible again after the next census.

One resident asked why CDBG money had not been sought to help reopen Hope, and suggested funding a study of what industries could be attracted to the area other than those extracting resources and polluting the community. Mulvena said the grant runs on an annual cycle and this hearing is the one opportunity to propose projects.

Two residents recommended sidewalks, trees and lighting on 9th Street from Main Street down to Chester. A resident asked if the grant could be used to fix basketball and tennis courts in the park. The council president responded that the basketball nets were removed according to a recommendation from the police because they attracted what he called the wrong kind of crowd, and the tennis courts were vandalized while they were considering updating them. Council also noted that there are plans for general maintenance at the parks next year.

The borough engineer stated that the council will select two projects to include in the grant application. A resident asked if the process of selecting the two projects can be made public, so that residents can see how the council chooses them. Council responded that the vote to approve two projects will be public. The deliberation itself could happen at the council meeting, but they are not required to hold it publicly. Applications are due Jan. 8.

Budget and approvals

In the Borough Manager's report, Mark Possenti discussed the new budget. There is no increase in property taxes, but there is a $40 annual increase in the trash fee to $375. He noted that because there is no change to the property tax, this change does not require an ordinance and advertisement to notify residents. Council passed the change as a resolution instead.

Council also approved an acquisition of property at 0 Fifth St. for a public works building for $39,000 using funding from a Local Share Account grant, and authorized a $900,000 LSA application for next year toward acquisition and construction of a new public works garage. They approved October paid bills for $166,510.21 and October paid payroll of $211,326.23. Mayor Maher swore in part-time police officers at the start of the meeting.

Know someone in Delco who should see this?

Read more